37 Comments

Swaroop

January 23, 2020

So nobody is gonna say that this movie is somewhat similar to Indian "Ashiqui " movie.

Reply

SKTW 890

January 23, 2020

Why does Bradley Cooper look like Kurt Cobain here?

Reply

Jim Thomas

January 23, 2020

what an insult to the origional

Reply

Cassandra Cataldo

January 23, 2020

I thought he almost did a caricature of a bipolar man in silver linings so I wasn't thinking Bradley Cooper could really assume a role to where I didn't see Bradley Cooper anymore- totally wrong. He must have always wanted to play this old alcoholic rockstar man.. I think the accent helped him assume a different role and he did great with the chemistry- thought the bathtub fight scene was great… it's how and why couples fight, just trying to pull each other down and hurt. Sam Elliot- best part but that's just because I love Sam Elliot lol

Reply

Kiko

January 23, 2020

that garage scene gets me every time 😢

Reply

Aryan Hegde

January 23, 2020

A star is born and another faded.

Reply

Oscar S

January 23, 2020

Movie is garbage. Why have movie makers abandoned originality.

Reply

walker11288

January 23, 2020

Thought it was a terrible movie. Poor character construction. Poor pacing. A serial killer could have come in and killed every character and I wouldn't have cared. Could not relate to the characters and felt little empathy towards them. Music was pretty good, but it's not good enough to save this movie.

Reply

Move_I_Got_This

January 23, 2020

It is a good movie, the music is the best part especially "Shallow".
Sam Eliot hit a grand slam.
Lady Gaga did great for a rookie but certainly not award winning, as if the Oscars had any credit left. Tony Collette and Tilda Swinton give the performances of their careers and they didn't even get nominated, Lady Gaga won Best Actress……that's political bullshit.
Bradley Cooper tried to act like Sam, which makes sense because they are brothers, but he was inconsistent.

Reply

Pratap jung Karki

January 23, 2020

absolute loved it

Reply

Drake

January 23, 2020

Andrew Dice Clay deserves mention as well. He was nearly unrecognizable and knocked his role of her dad out of the park.

Reply

Jesse 1437

January 23, 2020

Anyone who cries while watching a movie star in an interview…….

Reply

Jesse 1437

January 23, 2020

The funny guy from the hangover, and in other movies he’s just magnificent.

W
T
F

Reply

Rafaela M. Russi

January 23, 2020

He will always be Will from Alias.

Reply

J Gunzler

January 23, 2020

Loved it. I had to fight back tears several times in this. Every actor in here was incredible.

Reply

Jordan Harrington

January 23, 2020

I just watched this and literally tugged at my soul 😭

Reply

Dillon Smith

January 23, 2020

Both Bradley and lady? I guess. Played their characters well but I think this movie is overrated.

Reply

Mag

January 23, 2020

Unpopular opinion: I think Bradley cooper overacted in this movie. He was just so tragic, seemed like he was gonna cry in every scene and his voice was so crooky inaudible. He seriously was the most damaged character I’ve ever witnessed, no arc just tragic the whole way through

Reply

moviebuff1275

January 23, 2020

nahhh this movie is a B- (okay drama, not so good romance)

Reply

Pramod Kharat

January 23, 2020

Movie is directly derivative to 2013 Bollywood movie Ashiqui 2. Only difference is alcohol and drugs.

Reply

Phil Schwab

January 23, 2020

Co-wrote by Eli Roth… let that sink in lol

Reply

vishal debnath

January 23, 2020

This movie is remake copy of Bollywood flim Aashiqui 2.

Reply

Diego Ramos24

January 23, 2020

Ok I know it's all opinion but really? Lady Gaga one of the best singers of today? Really? I'm sorry but with all those weird noises she makes in her songs I can't agree with that, when it comes to modern musicians I'll gladly take System of a Down, Foo Fighters, or Avenged Sevenfold over her. Those are true musicians that combine great vocals with excellent instrument playing, not to mention they sing about serious issues.

Reply

Tu Nguyen

January 23, 2020

this movie sucks giant cheese balls.

Reply

Satyendra Choudhary

January 23, 2020

It's kinda late, still I watched this movie just because of your review. There is no doubt this is an awesome movie. I just wanna tell you that its inspired or copied from an Indian movie name Aashiqui 2. I just knew what's coming next, scene by scene. And by the way, yes , it is better in many ways than the original one. May be best of Bradley Cooper ever.

Reply

akshay bhalavi

January 23, 2020

Hold on a sec guys….its an remake of Indian movie ashiqui 2 which was a huge success for its story and music…

Reply

Patrick Clark

January 23, 2020

I am sorry but, this movie pissed me off because Bradley Cooper's character showed SO many signs of depression and desperation yet nobody really tried to help him. They ignored it and let him kill himself while riding off his success. In the end Sam Elliot says it's not your fault and I call bullshit. People need to be honest and aware of the people in their lives and when someone shows that many signs of desperation they need help and are looking for someone to help them. I've seen it many times throughout my life and when people fail to be there for a friend, a spouse, or a sibling it shows and then they are shocked when the worst happens. This stuff is preventable, but it takes awareness, care, and a friend to help people through these situations. I wish the best of luck and my prayers to anyone who deals with these issues. I hope you have someone in your life to steer you in the right direction, love, and help you through your struggles. Imo this movie doesn't do much in helping people in those situations and promotes the thought that no one is to blame but the person who "did the deed". THIS IS FALSE. Be aware and help the people in your lives. Thank you for reading.

Reply

Shaine MacDonald

January 23, 2020

This is actually the 4th time this movie has been remade with new cultural changes to the script!

Reply

Carlos Miguel Ugalde

January 23, 2020

fuckin shill

Reply

Goof Ball

January 23, 2020

Sam Elliott was a joke in this movie a big cry baby!!
BOO HOO!!

Reply

Goof Ball

January 23, 2020

1st half hr was good but went downhill fast totally predictable and way too long Best part was when he pissed his pants and then killed himself….. WHAT A JOKE

Reply

Estevan Alameda

January 23, 2020

The music was so goddamn good! I love the music. But this movie sucks so bad.

Reply

Alan David

January 23, 2020

Wow it really feels like I'm the only person in this comment section that didn't think this movie was amazing. It was 7/10 at best for me. It's emotional bait that didn't catch me.

Reply

Aztec Raider

January 23, 2020

Love u Chris but this was a very meh review. You kinda went through the motions. I also think u undervalued the movie I thought it was awesome 10/10.

Reply

Ariel Or

January 23, 2020

The movie is pure shit…..
I could not listen to the songs and skipped them after 30 seconds
You are all on crack

Reply

John Smitherson

January 23, 2020

Overrated movie. This is movie didn't do anything for me and I cry in The Lego Movie 2…yeah.

Reply

WonderWoman Tiffany

January 23, 2020

I just finished watching this and wow I loved it

A+

11/10

Reply

Leave a Reply